unilad homepage
unilad homepage
  • News
    • UK News
    • US News
    • World News
    • Crime
    • Health
    • Money
    • Sport
    • Travel
  • Music
  • Technology
  • Film and TV
    • News
    • DC Comics
    • Disney
    • Marvel
    • Netflix
  • Celebrity
  • Politics
  • Advertise
  • Terms
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • LADbible Group
  • LADbible
  • SPORTbible
  • GAMINGbible
  • Tyla
  • UNILAD Tech
  • FOODbible
  • License Our Content
  • About Us & Contact
  • Jobs
  • Latest
  • Archive
  • Topics A-Z
  • Authors
Facebook
Instagram
X
Threads
TikTok
YouTube
Submit Your Content
Star Trek fans spot huge plot hole in original series and question why it wasn't fixed
Home>Film & TV
Updated 21:11 10 Sep 2024 GMT+1Published 21:10 10 Sep 2024 GMT+1

Star Trek fans spot huge plot hole in original series and question why it wasn't fixed

A variant, perhaps?

Stefania Sarrubba

Stefania Sarrubba

google discoverFollow us on Google Discover
Featured Image Credit: NBC

Topics: Star Trek, Film and TV

Stefania Sarrubba
Stefania Sarrubba

Advert

Advert

Advert

As far as continuity errors go, Star Trek features a pretty big mistake in episode three of the original 1960s TV series.

Fans of the cult sci-fi franchise have spotted a name mix-up in episode three of Star Trek: The Original Series titled 'Where No Man Has Gone Before'.

First aired in September 1966, the episode introduced William Shatner as Captain James T Kirk, the man at the helm of the USS Enterprise.

The episode sees Kirk and the rest of the Enterprise crew against one of their own, helmsman Gary Mitchell (Gary Lockwood).

Advert

Mitchell gains telekinetic abilities when the Enterprise crosses the edge of the galaxy during a rescue mission gone wrong.

'Where No Man Has Gone Before' is the only Star Trek episode featuring the ship's psychiatrist, Dr Elisabeth Dehner. (NBC)
'Where No Man Has Gone Before' is the only Star Trek episode featuring the ship's psychiatrist, Dr Elisabeth Dehner. (NBC)

A power-hungry Mitchell becomes increasingly hostile and arrogant and declares he has become godlike, trying to enforce his will onto the crew by using his powers.

In one scene, Mitchell taunts Kirk by showing him the tombstone he's prepared for him, which reads James R Kirk - and many considered it odd as Kirk's middle name is Tiberius.

And fans were quick to pick up on it - with many struggling to find a reason for it.

On Reddit, one person wrote that despite some theories, there was 'no hard canon explanation for it'.

Another said: "Why didn’t they fix that? Obviously there has been enough times where it has been established that Kirk’s middle initial begins with a T."

And a third joked: "The person who signed Kirk up for Starfleet was a rubbish touch typist."

Is the middle initial slip simply an error, or is there an explanation for it?

It seems that Star Trek creator Gene Roddenberry provided fans with a sensible justification hinging on Mitchell's inherent humanity.

The grave reads James R Kirk (NBC)
The grave reads James R Kirk (NBC)

According to DC Fontana in the introduction for Star Trek: The Classic Episodes 1, when the mistake over the consonant confusion was discovered, the Star Trek creator decided that, if pressed for an answer on the discrepancy, he would shift the blame on Mitchell.

"Gary Mitchell had godlike powers, but at base he was human," Roddenberry said as reported by The Daily Star. "He made a mistake."

This was but one of the errors and plot holes included in the whole of the Star Trek franchise, though even more modern TV series and films have puzzled fans with some mistakes that ended up making the final cut.

A few years have passed since Game of Thrones fans noticed the infamous Starbucks cup in season 8 of the show, while Stranger Things creators, the Duffer brothers, admitted that they've considered retconning Will Byers' birthday after viewers spotted an incongruence.

Choose your content:

6 hours ago
14 hours ago
a day ago
3 days ago
  • Netflix
    6 hours ago

    All the horrifying details of Taylor Parker crime scene that were left out of Maternal Instinct

    Netflix’s latest true crime series follows the heinous crimes of Taylor Parker

    Film & TV
  • Netflix
    14 hours ago

    I Will Find You is Netflix’s best Harlan Coben adaption in years after two key changes

    Netflix's latest Harlan Coben series premieres today (June 18)

    Film & TV
  • Hulu
    a day ago

    Nannies for the super rich must follow bizarre requirements in new Hulu reality TV show

    A group of nannies (and mannies) jet off to Ibiza for the summer in Hulu's addictive new series, Million Dollar Nannies

    Film & TV
  •  Aidan Monaghan/HBO
    3 days ago

    HBO’s Harry Potter series casts fan-favourite character who was famously cut from the movies

    Peeves the Poltergeist will be making his on-screen debut in the upcoming series

    Film & TV
  • Huge plot hole in Bridgerton season 4 raises questions around key storyline but there's still a way to fix it
  • NBC slashes schedule with 9 shows axed including 96% rated series
  • HBO’s Harry Potter series casts fan-favourite character who was famously cut from the movies
  • Fox accused of breaking huge FIFA broadcasting rule in first World Cup 2026 game