• News
  • Film and TV
  • Music
  • Tech
  • Features
  • Celebrity
  • Politics
  • Weird
  • Community
  • Advertise
  • Terms
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • LADbible Group
  • LADbible
  • SPORTbible
  • GAMINGbible
  • Tyla
  • UNILAD Tech
  • FOODbible
  • License Our Content
  • About Us & Contact
  • Jobs
  • Latest
  • Topics A-Z
  • Authors
Facebook
Instagram
X
Threads
TikTok
YouTube
Submit Your Content
People left 'extremely disturbed' after discovering what Halloween Jack O'Lanterns originally looked like

Home> News> US News

Published 20:24 30 Oct 2025 GMT

People left 'extremely disturbed' after discovering what Halloween Jack O'Lanterns originally looked like

Traditionally, pumpkins weren't even the vegetable being carved out

Joe Yates

Joe Yates

The original Jack O'Lanterns were nothing like they are today - they were carved out of a different vegetable entirely, and were so spooky they've left some people 'extremely disturbed'.

Before pumpkins became the go-to Halloween decoration, people in Ireland were carving turnips into creepy faces to keep evil spirits away.

According to the National Museum of Ireland, these terrifying creations were part of Oíche Shamhna, or Samhain, the ancient Celtic festival marking when the barrier between the living and the dead was weakest.

“Candles were placed inside the turnips and they were used to frighten people on the night of 31 October,” the museum explains.

Advert

Some were even carved from potatoes, because apparently, nothing says Halloween like a haunted spud.

But after similar photos were shared on Twitter, users likely experienced their first scare of the festive season!

"A reminder that the original jack o' lanterns date back to 18th century Ireland if not earlier, were based on a shady boozy blacksmith called Stingy Jack who cheated the devil & was trapped between 2 worlds, were carved from turnips and looked like this," they wrote, accompanied by some pretty terrifying-looking turnips.

That is one scary-looking turnip - which must've taken ages to carve! (National Museum of Ireland)
That is one scary-looking turnip - which must've taken ages to carve! (National Museum of Ireland)

Advert

One user wrote: "These are extremely disturbing!"

With a second typing: "And bloody hard to carve too."

Yes, trying to remove the 'insides' of a turnip I imagine would be much harder than taking the inners of a pumpkin out - and that sentiment is evidenced by some in the comments.

One of which highlighted: "That's what we had growing up. My mum didn't trust us with knives so she made us carve our turnips out with a spoon. Do you have any idea how long that took?

Advert

We can thank the US for our more kid-friendly Jack O'Lanterns (Getty stock)
We can thank the US for our more kid-friendly Jack O'Lanterns (Getty stock)

While another added: "I’m 52 and grew up in North East England. We had carved turnips not pumpkins, the smell of singed turnip is something I’ll never forget. It was so hard to carve, actually nearly impossible to hollow out, that it needed Dad to do it."

The museum also notes: “The pumpkin that is prevalent today is an American development of this Irish tradition.”

Basically, the US took the idea, swapped the rock-hard turnips for pumpkins, and made it a lot less traumatising.

Advert

As for the name, it comes from the eerie Irish folktale of Jack - 'who was welcome neither in Heaven nor Hell and was destined to wander the countryside forever, with just a lantern to light the way'.

If Jack’s lantern looked anything like those creepy turnips, we get why he’s still wandering.

Featured Image Credit: Getty stock

Topics: Halloween, Ireland

Joe Yates
Joe Yates

Joe is a journalist for UNILAD, who particularly enjoys writing about crime. He has worked in journalism for five years, and has covered everything from murder trials to celeb news.

X

@JMYjourno

Advert

Advert

Advert

Choose your content:

6 hours ago
7 hours ago
  • Getty Images/agrobacter
    6 hours ago

    Scientists discover breakthrough 'cure' for hair loss which takes just 20 days

    If testing is successful, it could be sold as a skincare product

    News
  • CNN
    6 hours ago

    Obama praised for 'smooth' way he dealt with heckler at rally

    The former president was supporting a Democratic hopeful at a rally

    News
  • Getty Images/Scott Olson/Getty Images/Andrew Harnik
    6 hours ago

    Eye-opening poll reveals whether Americans prefer Obama or Trump as president

    The insight comes ahead of gubernatorial elections on Tuesday

    News
  • Getty Images/Andrew Harnik
    7 hours ago

    People extremely concerned after Trump blasts Seth Meyers for being 'illegally anti-Trump'

    Seth Meyers ridiculed President Donald Trump's tour of Asia, and it's fair to say the Republican wasn't best pleased

    News
  • People terrified after seeing what a child's skull looks like
  • Fans defend The Rock after he revealed 'slim' look which has left people extremely concerned
  • People mind-blown after seeing what Squid Game looks like without CGI
  • People are stunned after man reveals what speaking English actually sounds like to foreigners